• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Papa Luigi Pizzeria

At Papa Luigi Pizzeria, we celebrate the joy of family and flavor. Nestled in Woodstown, NJ, this charming pizzeria captures the essence of a beloved "mom and pop" establishment. Known for its inviting atmosphere and heartfelt service, Papa Luigi delights customers with a tempting menu that features a variety of pizzas, pastas, and appetizers like their famed garlic knots. The pizzeria is perfect for families and groups, offering takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating. Whether you're indulging in a hearty pasta flight or savoring a slice of their perfect pizza, every visit feels like a warm, delicious embrace from home.

Papa Luigi Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Melissa G.
Melissa G.

When we arrived it was SUPER busy, which is always a good thing! The place was a quaint "mom and pop" kind of feel which we loved! We came for the pasta flights so we didn't mind waiting for a table! The servers were very friendly and helpful! We ordered the pasta flights which came with a side salad bar and also came with garlic knots! The garlic knots were to die for! They were the perfect texture and seasoned t perfection! The pasta flight was amazing! We got the marinara spaghetti, fettuccine Alfredo and pesto penne! All of them were really tasty but the one we loved the best was the pesto penne! It was so tasty and creamy! This was such a cool way to try different pastas and find one you love! If you're in the area give them a try and follow them on Facebook. They always post updates and new menu items!

Dave R.
Dave R.

All around Awsome family food ,atmosphere, and service! Food came out fast and hot and delicious

Amanda P.
Amanda P.

i LOVEEEEE this place!!!!! the pizza is absolute perfection . their pizza seriously makes new jersey proud (believe me) ! they are always so pleasant and kind & i love love love the lay out & decor of their building. reminds me of home & family. i am so happy to have found this resturaunt especially after moving down here from Burlington county. keep doing what you're doing papa luigi's!!!! we love you

Matt C.
Matt C.

Definitely more of a three and a half. The food is actually the weak link, as the place was very nice and clean, and the servers were extremely polite and friendly. We were in the area and just wanted a quick bite, so we stopped here. The inside was very nice upon entering, and the hostess was so nice and accommodating for some crayons for my little one. The server took a little while to get to us, but when she did, she was very nice. But, that's the end of the superlatives. The food, which wasn't BAD, was also certainly nothing you would be in a hurry to get back to. Everything tasted ok, but 1) the Margherita pizza arrived with a PUDDLE on it from the fresh mozzarella, the chicken in the chicken wrap was fried a little too hard, and the buffalo wings must have come off of a hummingbird. I've never seen wings that small; $.99 cents a wing. Ugh. I rounded them up instead of down, because of the location and service, but the food could definitely use a tiny tweak. I wouldn't avoid Papa Luigi's, but I'm in no rush to get back. They DID have a sweet ass Gucci Fiat in the parking lot too.

Randi P.
Randi P.

We came for the $19.99 pasta flight of course! At around 4:45pm, the wait for 2 was about 45 minutes. We didn't mind as there is a brewery across the street. When we were texted about our table being available, we arrived and were promptly served. The pasta is very good and worth coming for! I especially loved the gnocchi in pesto cream. The salad bar is underwhelming but a nice addition nonetheless. The ambiance was decorated for Christmas and very cozy. You definitely feel like you're one of the family here as the workers come by to check on you and clear your plates frequently while making small talk. We will be back!

Stephanie B.
Stephanie B.

10/10 would recommend! We came for the pasta flights! $19.99! It's your classic pizzeria with a dining room. Small salad bar that did the job came with our flights and so did garlic knots and bread. It was a busy evening. The flights are done on Tuesdays. So many combinations - I did the gnocchi with Papa Luigi sauce, fusilli with arrabbiata sauce and linguini with vodka sauce. The vodka was my favorite, next the arrabbiata, followed by the pasta Luigi sauce. Next time I will skip the gnocchi- it was good but heavy as expected! Go now! Grab friends and eat up!

Gigi A.
Gigi A.

Found a jem in Woodstown seen post for pasta flights n had to come n try it. The carbs went out the window! We had 6 different pastas with 6 different sauces. Each one was delicious! They serve the flights on Tuesday only. Be prepare to wait a little while. We will be back! Staff was so friendly which was a bonus and the pizza was just how I like it thin n crispy. We highly recommend this place. Prices are very reasonable n it's a byob. OMG the desserts were heavenly. Ricotta pistachio cake n a lemon cello cake. More please! I even hate to give them a good review cause I don't want it to be crowded when we come lol

Deb P.
Deb P.

I visited Papa Luigi's after a stressful day with my mom who had been in the hospital. I wanted comforting, delicious, nourishing food. I was told I could bring my own wine, so hurried to the shop for a good red then returned. I was warmly greeted and asked to select a table of my liking. The parts menu was extensive and creative. I chose a puttanesca and was extremely glad I did. It was rich with squeezed tomatoes, slivers of garlic, briny capers, olives and just enough red peppers. The garlic rolls were outstanding - warm and soft, just the right amount of garlic. I started with a lovely salad and house vinaigrette that was just enough. I left with plenty of pasta to reheat for the next days main meal. I would highly recommend a visit to Papa Luigi when your Italian taste buds need satiating. Mangia!

Location

Welcome to Papa Luigi Pizzeria, a charming eatery nestled in the heart of Woodstown, NJ, at 39 N Main St. This delightful pizzeria goes beyond the pizza parlor stereotype, offering a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of a beloved family gathering spot. With a reputation built on both mouth-watering dishes and friendly service, it’s no wonder that patrons rave about their experiences.

Papa Luigi Pizzeria provides an array of options that cater to every craving. Whether you're stopping by for a delightful lunch or a cozy family dinner, there's something for everyone on the menu. The pizzeria is equipped for casual dining, takeout, or delivery, making it convenient for those on the go. With outdoor seating available, you can enjoy your meal in the fresh air—perfect for sunny days.

  • Popular Menu Items:
  • Papa Luigi's Assortment: A delightful mix of chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, poppers, and onion rings for just $8.99.
  • Soup of the Day: A hearty option starting at just $5.49.
  • Tossed Salad: A fresh medley of lettuce, croutons, cucumbers, tomatoes, sweet peppers, and onions for only $5.49.
  • Plain Cheese Pizza: A classic choice at $12.49.
  • Pepperoni Stromboli: Packed with pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and sauce for $15.49.

What truly sets Papa Luigi Pizzeria apart is the customer experience. Many reviewers have praised the friendly and accommodating staff. Melissa G. mentioned how busy the place was, a sign of good food and a thriving kitchen. Her highlight was the pasta flight, which included delicious garlic knots that had patrons coming back for more. Meanwhile, Amanda P’s enthusiastic review emphasized the perfection of their pizza—a true Jersey classic that warms the heart and satisfies the palate.

For those with a family, Papa Luigi Pizzeria also caters to groups, offering a family-friendly vibe where kids can enjoy their meals in a cozy, relaxed environment. The feedback on the ambiance is consistently positive, with many noting the homey decor that makes you feel like part of the family.

While there have been mixed reviews on some dishes, such as a less-than-stellar Margherita pizza, it’s clear that Papa Luigi Pizzeria strives to create a welcoming experience for its guests. The camaraderie and family-oriented service often leave a lasting impression, making it a spot worth revisiting.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Papa Luigi Pizzeria promises a delightful culinary adventure. With the right mix of casual dining, friendly service, and a menu that caters to diverse tastes, it’s easy to see why so many keep coming back. Don't forget to follow them on Facebook for updates and new menu items!